Neck Warmers?

(l-r): American Apparel, Etsy, Marc Jacobs.

What do you think? Yay or nay? I was about to purchase the yellow neck warmer from American Apparel, but then I thought - am I really gonna wear this? It's super cute, but I don't wear turtlenecks to begin with so would a neck warmer be any different? I could see where a neck warmer would be adorable with a cute trench coat. But what about with just a sweater? Hmmmm....dunno. Maybe I'm just attracted to the cute buttons.